Sleep all the sleep (part 1)

If you’ve read any of the posts I’ve made you’ve already heard my recommendation to get more sleep. In fact if you read any of the blogs that I read, you’ve read a few other sciency posts on why sleep is important.  Stephen Guyenet outlines a study in this one that found that people who got more sleep lost more weight from fat when they lost weight.

There’s a lot of information about why you should sleep more.  Many of us don’t get enough for a variety of reasons.  I have a strong feeling that our reduced sleep time is as influential as any other single factor in the rise of obesity.  The CDC calls it a public health epidemic!

That report says: “According to data from the National Health Interview Survey, nearly 30% of adults reported an average of ≤6 hours of sleep per day in 2005-2007. In 2009, only 31% of high school students reported getting at least 8 hours of sleep on an average school night.”

Ok, so it seems pretty clear that lots of people aren’t getting enough sleep.  I think there’s a lot of emphasis on the effects on our movement and exercise when we are not getting enough sleep.  I’d like to highlight some big picture studies that talk about some of the hormonal impacts that occur from even short term sleep reduction.

We all know that one of the goals of exercise is to improve insulin sensitivity.  Well these two studies show that just 7 days of 4-5 hours of sleep resulted in signs associated with insulin resistance in healthy young men:

In one of the studies they tried to attenuate the effect with modafinil, an alertness medication, which had no effect.  This shows that it’s not just “fatigue” causing the metabolic changes, it’s neurohumoral.  The reduced sleep causes real modifications in the people’s biology.

The gurus try to tell us that it’s the carbs increasing our appetite.  Lustig is selling a “sugar blocks leptin” theory also.  That has some merit to it, but what if it was more simple then that?  What if we are sleeping on average 2 hours less per night then 40 years ago and THAT is making us hungry.  What if wide swaths of America are overweight as much because we stay up too late watching TV or doing facebook?  Well I’ve been thinking that may be the case ever since I saw this doozy:

This is a great study.  It was a group of normal weight but relatively sedentary individuals. They were brought into the hospital and all their food was measured, but they could eat ad-lib.  They were split into two groups and spent 2 nights in the lab getting used to the environment and getting their food measured, etc.  Sleeping how much they wanted the first nights the groups were matched for sleep.  Then they took the experimental group and limited them to 2/3 their normal, which in the study was an average of 5.2 hours while the control group continued to sleep an average of about 7 hours.  This lasted for 8 nights.  They continued to measure both groups calorie intake during that time and also measured their activity through a physical activity monitoring system (PAMS).

The results are pretty surprising.  Mostly surprising at how big the change is.  No change in activity levels between groups.  No change to levels of ghrelin or leptin (which was actually the hypothesis).  Huge change to calorie intake.  The sleep deprived group increased intake by over 600 calories and the control group decreased by about 100 calories per day during the experimental period.  Let me repeat: an hour and a half decreased sleep resulted in a nearly 600 calorie increase in intake.  This persisted even after two recovery nights (where the experimental group slept a lot more than their baseline) with the calorie intake still being increased by ~150 kcal.  This resulted in a statistically significant increase in weight over the study period of 0.9 kg (~2 pounds).in less than two weeks.

There are some limitations to the study. The groups were small and the experimental group had a much lower baseline intake during the free living period. This could imply some baseline metabolic differences between the two groups, but even that doesn’t bother me. Even without a control group this would be an interesting result.  The fact that the controls aren’t perfectly matched, but still had roughly static intake during the study period does help suggest the increase in intake is heavily influenced by the sleep deprivation.

By sleep deprivation of course I mean, “being forced to sleep like large portions of the American population.”

Go to bed.


13 thoughts on “Sleep all the sleep (part 1)

  1. I love sleeping. I don’t understand how most adults are still alive, much less ambulatory, on the amount of sleep they (claim) to get. I sometimes wonder if it’s like a calorie-estimating thing, where people are just spectacularly bad at estimating their input/output? Or are people really, truly surviving on just 5 hours of sleep a night day-in, day-out, for years and years?

    • I really think they are actually. I think 5-6 hours is amazingly common. Lots of my patients start early or work swing shift, but don’t make adjustments to bed time and just live off no sleep.

      I think there’s even more people like my mom that spend the first few hours sleeping with the TV on, light on, restless, etc, before they finally turn everything off and get 5-6 hours of good quiet quality sleep.

    • Until six years ago, I had a high-stress job that demanded I work tons of hours. If I slept five hours, I considered myself lucky. (This was my life for two decades, and unfortunately, this sleep pattern followed through to weekends.) And I wondered why I was always hungry. Now that I am sleeping eight hours a night — and believe me, it’s taken years to get into this pattern — I understand what well rested is all about. Plus, my eating is under control, I make time for exercise, and I am overall much healthier. I had no idea my job was killing me.

  2. Thank you for this. It matches my experience–if I am tired, I try to make up for the cruddy feeling of “tired” by eating more. My mind is trying to fix the problem in the only available way.
    I would like to sleep more. My kids are two and four. Maybe in a couple of years… For now I will get off WordPress and go to bed.

  3. I try to get at least 8 hours of sleep per night, but sometimes I have trouble falling asleep, especially if I don’t have a set routine (ie. during the summer).

    Could you maybe write a post on snoring and/or sleep apnea?

    • Part 2 will be on getting a good nights sleep which depending on length will talk about sleep apnea. Most people (I said most, not all) with sleep apnea don’t have trouble falling asleep.

      • I don’t think I have sleep apnea (I’m seeing a specialist soon, though), but I do snore. 😦 I don’t think it’s weight related either, as I also snored as a child, when I was very slim. Could be related to adenoid/tonsils, but my otolaryngologists doesn’t seem to think so.

        As for having trouble falling assleep, it happens when I can’t shut my brain off and it races from one thought to another, hah.

  4. Can I LOVE this instead of like it? My body makes me PAY when I don’t get enough sleep. I am tired,crabby, and just in general do not want to be productive. It’s awful! Working out is less likely, and healthy food decisions are out the door!

  5. Pingback: Sleep all the Sleep (part 3) | Go Maleo

  6. Pingback: Operation Feel Good Week 9 - Going Reno

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s